Amazon Self Publishing has revolutionized the writing world, providing avenues like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) for aspiring authors to share their stories.
With the click of a button, a manuscript draft can transform into print books or ebooks, available on platforms such as Kindle Unlimited or Amazon Book. But while self-publishing offers accessibility, some argue it doesn’t compare to the expertise and benefits of professional publishing.
If you’re an author weighing the pros and cons of self-publishing vs. traditional publishing, this article breaks down key considerations—from quality and marketing to finances and long-term reach—so you can choose the publishing path that best suits your goals.
Photo by Robert Anasch on Unsplash
Amazon Self Publishing vs. Professional Publishing
Amazon KDP has become synonymous with self-publishing. It offers full control over the publishing process, quick turnaround times, affordability, and the ability to upload your manuscript for free. But is it enough to properly publish a book?
Pros of Amazon KDP:
- Control: Authors manage everything, from their book cover to pricing.
- Speed: Skip lengthy processes—your book can be live in a few days.
- Affordability: There’s no upfront cost to self-publish your ebook version or paperback book.
Cons of Amazon KDP:
- Quality Limitations: Many authors struggle with professional book cover design and editing.
- Competition: The platform is saturated with millions of similar books, including amateur works.
- Lack of Support: Without a dedicated team, indie authors carry the entire publishing burden themselves.
Now, compare that with professional publishing, where traditional publishers bring years of industry expertise.
Pros of Professional Publishing:
- Quality: Professional editing, formatting, and cover design elevate a book’s appeal.
- Marketing Support: Traditional publishers often handle pre-sale strategies, book launches, and distribution.
- Global Reach: With comprehensive networks, professional publishers help books reach readers worldwide.
- Versatility: Traditional publishers offer professional editing, formatting, and cover design for paperback, ebook, and hardcover book versions.
Cons of Professional Publishing:
- Limited Control: Publishers handle decision-making on areas like pricing and cover design.
- Time-Intensive: The whole process, from manuscript submission to release, can take a year or longer.
- Higher Barriers to Entry: Publishers often accept only select manuscripts, leaving many aspiring authors out.
Both routes have merits, but professional publishing ensures a polished product ready to compete at higher industry standards.
Photo by CHUTTERSNAP on Unsplash
The Reality of Self-Publishing on Amazon
Self-publishing on Amazon can be a rewarding experience, but it’s essential to understand the reality of the process. With millions of books available on Amazon, the competition is fierce, and authors need to be prepared to put in the effort to make their book stand out.
While platforms like Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) make it easy to self publish, the sheer volume of content means that simply uploading your manuscript isn’t enough.
Authors must invest time and resources into marketing, cover design, and ensuring their book is professionally edited and formatted. Without these efforts, even the most compelling stories can get lost in the sea of available titles.
Quality and Design: Book Cover
When it comes to attracting readers, first impressions matter. A poorly designed book title or amateurish cover design may steer potential readers away from your book on Amazon.
With Amazon KDP, tools like KDP’s Cover Creator provide basic templates to help design book covers. However, these often lack the finesse necessary to stand out. On the other hand, professional publishers offer access to experienced designers who tailor book covers for market trends, genre expectations, and target audiences.
Similarly, editing can be a costly hurdle for self-published books. While some indie authors re-read their manuscripts meticulously, others hire freelance editors. But without a professional publisher’s editorial team, self-published books often skip professional-quality editing, resulting in avoidable errors.
Simply put, professional publishers ensure both the front cover and contents of your book leave a lasting impression.
Photo by 愚木混株 cdd20 on Unsplash
The Importance of Editing and Formatting
Editing and formatting are crucial steps in the self-publishing process. A well-edited and formatted book can make a significant difference in how readers perceive the author’s work. Editing helps to ensure that the book is free of errors, flows smoothly, and is engaging to read. Formatting, on the other hand, ensures that the book looks professional and is easy to read on various devices.
Amazon offers a range of tools and resources to help authors with editing and formatting, including Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) Select, which provides access to professional editing and formatting services.
However, authors can also hire freelance editors and formatters or use self-publishing platforms that offer these services. Investing in these aspects can elevate a self-published book to the standards of traditional publishing, making it more appealing to readers.
The Role of Cover Design in Self-Publishing
A book cover is often the first thing that readers notice, and it can play a significant role in determining whether they will buy the book. A well-designed cover can help to grab the reader’s attention, convey the book’s genre and tone, and establish the author’s brand.
Amazon’s KDP platform offers a range of cover design tools, including KDP’s Cover Creator, which allows authors to create their own covers using pre-designed templates and images.
However, authors can also hire professional cover designers or use self-publishing platforms that offer cover design services. A professionally designed cover can make a self-published book stand out in a crowded marketplace, attracting more readers and boosting sales.
Distribution and Market Reach
Amazon KDP:
With Kindle Direct Publishing, your book’s primary marketplace is Amazon. It’s a fantastic starting point, but relying solely on Amazon limits the book’s potential reach to specific audiences already browsing this platform.
Professional Publishers:
Traditional publishers offer unparalleled distribution networks. Books published through these channels are distributed to major retailers like Barnes & Noble and may even adorn the shelves of local bookstores. These networks help your paperback and hardcover books reach readers around the world.
What About Libraries?
Libraries often support professionally published books, granting access to new audiences who might not find your content on Kindle Unlimited.
While Amazon and Kindle are giants in the book-selling world, professional publishers can expand your readership significantly through varied platforms.
Marketing and Promotion
One of the biggest challenges self-published authors face is effective marketing. Amazon KDP provides limited tools for promotion, like discounted pricing during a book launch or enrolling in KDP Select for Kindle ebook visibility. However, competition is fierce, with countless similar books vying for attention.
Professional publishers take much of the guesswork out of marketing. They assign publicists, arrange media coverage, and create detailed marketing plans to ensure a book reaches its intended age range and audience. They leverage connections with book bloggers, influencers, and bookstores to maximize exposure.
Marketing Tips for KDP Authors:
If you’re self-publishing with Amazon KDP, consider these strategies to build visibility for your book:
- Invest in high-quality cover design to captivate potential buyers.
- Run targeted ads using Amazon’s advertising platform to stand out in the sea of ebooks.
- Build an author website to showcase your brand and engage readers.
- Tap into social media for organic advertising.
- Seek reviews on your paperback or ebook release to build trust and credibility.
Photo by Arif Riyanto on Unsplash
Financial Considerations
Amazon KDP:
Self-publishing platforms like Kindle Direct promise attractive royalty options, ranging from 35% to 70%. This means authors retain a significant share of book sales revenue. Additionally, there are no upfront costs for uploading your manuscript to sell paperback versions or ebooks.
Professional Publishing:
With traditional publishing, royalties are typically lower—often around 10–15%—since the publisher absorbs production, editing, and marketing costs. However, professional publishers often pay authors an advance upfront, enabling financial security while fine-tuning the final product.
Which option is more profitable? That depends on how well an author markets their self-published book or whether their professional publisher gives them a breakout hit.
Photo by Kimberly Farmer on Unsplash
The Process of Self-Publishing on Amazon
Self-publishing on Amazon involves several steps, from creating an account to publishing the book. Here’s an overview of the process:
Creating an Amazon KDP Account
To self-publish on Amazon, authors need to create a Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) account. This can be done by going to kdp.amazon.com and signing in with an Amazon account. If the author doesn’t have an Amazon account, they can create one by following the prompts.
Once the account is created, authors need to set up their author and publisher information, including their name, email address, and tax information. This information will be used to pay royalties and to identify the author as the publisher of the book.
After setting up the account, authors can start creating their book by clicking on the “Create a New Title” button. This will take them to a page where they can enter their book’s title, author name, and book description. They can also upload their book cover and manuscript at this stage.
The next step is to choose the book’s categories and keywords. This is an essential step, as it will help readers find the book when they search for it on Amazon. Authors can choose up to seven keywords and two categories for their book.
Finally, authors need to set their book’s price and royalty rate. Amazon offers a range of pricing options, including a 70% royalty rate for books priced between $2.99 and $9.99. Authors can also choose to enroll their book in Kindle Unlimited, which allows readers to borrow and read the book for a flat monthly fee.
Once all the information is entered, authors can click the “Publish” button to make their book live on Amazon. The book will be available for sale within 24 hours, and authors can start promoting it to their readers.
Success Stories
While Amazon self-publishing has propelled indie authors like Amanda Hocking to fame, she eventually transitioned to traditional publishing after recognizing its vast resources and reach. Similarly, traditionally published authors like J.K. Rowling achieved global phenomenon status thanks partly to their publishing team’s extensive support.
Each path offers opportunities for success, but aspiring authors should examine their goals. For some, becoming a self-published author is about control and creative freedom. For others, pursuing traditional publishing opens doors to new markets and career-defining partnerships.
Photo by Anastasia Zhenina on Unsplash
How to Choose the Right Self Publishing Route
The debate between self-publishing and using professional publishers doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer. It ultimately depends on your writing goals, budget, and the audience you hope to reach.
If you’re looking for complete autonomy and a cost-effective way to publish your book, Amazon KDP might be the right choice to publish your book quickly, offering various ebook formats and paperback options. But if your priority lies in producing a polished product with professional backing, traditional publishing can provide the support and expertise you’ll need to succeed.
Still confused? Start by asking yourself:
- Do I have the time and resources to manage the whole process myself?
- How important is global distribution and a professional marketing plan?
- Am I willing to relinquish some creative control for higher quality and reach?
Wherever your publishing journey takes you, remember that the most important thing is getting your manuscript into the hands of readers.
RGM International: Christian Publishing
RGM International is renowned for its dedication to promoting Christian literature across the globe. Specializing in faith-based publications, RGM provides a platform for authors to share messages of hope, inspiration, and spiritual growth. The publishing house offers a range of services tailored to Christian writers, including professional editing, cover design, and targeted marketing to reach faith communities.
By leveraging their established distribution networks, RGM ensures that books find their place in churches, religious bookstores, and online platforms dedicated to Christian content. Authors choosing RGM International benefit not only from expert publishing support but also from being part of a mission-driven community seeking to enrich readers’ spiritual lives.
Photo by Hannah Olinger on Unsplash
Resources for Aspiring Authors
Navigating the publishing process can be daunting, but numerous resources can assist authors at every stage. Here are some valuable links to explore:
- Writer’s Digest: A comprehensive resource offering advice on writing, publishing, and marketing.
- Reedsy: Connects authors with professional editors, designers, and marketers. Offers free courses and a wealth of information on self-publishing and traditional publishing.
- The Alliance of Independent Authors: Advocates for self-publishing and provides insights, legal advice, and promotional guidance for indie authors.
- QueryTracker: A tool to help writers track submissions to agents and publishers, with community forums for advice and support.
- IngramSpark: Offers print-on-demand services and global distribution for indie authors looking to expand their reach.
- Poets & Writers: Provides information on literary journals, grants, writing contests, and more, supporting the broader writing community.
- NaNoWriMo: Encourages writers to complete a novel in November, offering community support and motivation throughout the writing journey.
- Kirkus Reviews: Provides professional book review services that can significantly enhance the visibility and credibility of your work.
- Scrivener: A powerful writing software that helps authors organize their manuscripts, notes, and ideas.
- Pitch Wars: An annual mentorship program where published/agented authors, editors, or industry interns help emerging writers prepare their manuscripts for submission.
Formatting tools like Kindle Create can help authors design their book’s layout, including the title page, to ensure a professional appearance.
Leveraging these resources can enhance your writing journey and help bring your manuscript from draft to publication.